Pages

Showing posts with label ukba. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ukba. Show all posts

Monday, February 18, 2013

Are tougher visa rules putting Indian students off UK?



The number of Indian students studying in the UK fell for the first time the last year, many say due to changes in visa rules.
Ministers have come under fire for tightening the rules on post-study leave to remain in the UK which some businesses and universities believe is deterring people from applying.
As David Cameron prepares to visit the India, looks at how the issue affecting Indians' perception of Britain. pleas  visit following link  and comment

Sunday, December 9, 2012

Tier 4 – student visa extension case Failure to Apply rule Flexibility

Real case study 17 , after such a long time !!!

The applicant previously studied for a BSc in Computer Information Systems; made a new application to extend his leave to study for BSc in Computer Networking; the “CAS” did not state that this represented educational progression or complemented a previous course of study at the same level as required by the Immigration regulations.

VERITAS found that  Evidential Flexibility could have been used in this case because, even if academic progression was not being made, the fresh course could complement the previous course of study;
After intimation, Home office then examined the case again and told the decision was based on a previous  out–of-country visa application having been made for a level 6 course and the current application was also at level 6;  examined the records and found that the previous course was actually at Level 5 and therefore the new course did constitute academic progression; 

At last agreed that Evidential Flexibility should have been used in this case and that the case would be reviewed later Applicant got visa extended and currently enjoying student life  


Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Evidence by electronic means


An interesting case on the use of electronic means (telephone, video link, Skype, Morse, that sort of thing) has been determined in North Shields. As the tribunal comes close to saying, it is serendipitous that it should be here where this issue would arise again, after the notorious case of R (on the application of AM (Cameroon)) v Asylum and Immigration Tribunal [2007] EWCA Civ 131.
The official headnote to this new case, Nare (evidence by electronic means) Zimbabwe [2011] UKUT 00443 (IAC), reads as follows:
The decision whether to allow evidence to be given by electronic means is a judicial one, requiring consideration of the need to do so, the arrangements at the distant site, and the ability to assess such evidence, by reference to guidance such as that set out here.
In this case a decision had been made that a witness who could not afford to travel to North Shields would be permitted to give evidence by telephone. It was not known who had made the decision or what, if anything, they had considered or weighed in making that decision.
The Presenting Officer threw what is technically known as a hissy fit and refused to cross examine the witness. This is the equivalent of getting up and walking out if an adjournment application is refused. Ultimately this was the undoing of the Secretary of State’s appeal as it meant that the witnesses evidence was unchallenged. The smart thing to do might have been to ask a few questions such as “how do we know you are who you say you are?”
The tribunal, chaired by Deputy President Mr Ockelton, opines that in the common law there is a presumption that evidence will be given in person before the tribunal or court then goes on:
Departures from that model are likely to reduce the quality of evidence, the ability of the parties to test it, and the ability of the judge to assess it, particularly where it has to be assessed against other oral evidence. Any application to call oral evidence by electronic link therefore needs to be justified. There is a measure of agreement across common-law jurisdictions that the taking of evidence, or the hearing of submissions, in this way requires regulation and ought not to be regarded as routine.
Interestingly, from the point of view of immigration bail hearings, video linked evidence is now regarded as presumptive and routine, at least by the Immigration and Asylum Chamber powers that be, and a judicial decision that video link evidence will be permitted is certainly not made in individual cases. I’m pretty damn sure that video links are not used for bail hearings in the criminal or other courts. The liberty of mere migrants is the poor cousin to the liberty of free-born Englishmen.
It is also I think worth observing that this case opens the door to applying for special measures to enable children to give evidence in a friendly and safe environment. This would normally be considered to increase not diminish the quality of evidence given. See Chapter 4 on representing children in appeals in the recent ILPA publication Working With Refugee Children: Current Issues in Best Practice for ideas (disclosure: I wrote it).
The actual guidance given by the tribunal is given with the caveat that it amounts to minimum requirements and may well require adjustment over time:
a.      A party seeking to call evidence at an oral hearing by electronic link must notify all other parties and the Tribunal at the earliest possible stage, indicating (by way of witness statement) the content of the proposed evidence.  (If the evidence is uncontested, an indication of that from the other parties may enable the witness’ evidence to be taken wholly in writing.)
b.     An application to call evidence by electronic link must be made in sufficient time before the hearing to allow it to be dealt with properly.  The application should be made to the relevant judge (normally the Resident Senior Immigration Judge) at the hearing centre at which the hearing is to take place, and must give (i) the reason why the proposed witness cannot attend the hearing; (ii) an indication of what arrangements have been made provisionally at the distant site (iii) an undertaking to be responsible for any expenses incurred.
c.      The expectation ought to be that the distant site will be a court or Tribunal hearing centre, and that the giving of the evidence will be subject to on-site supervision by court or Tribunal staff.
d.     If the proposal is to give evidence from abroad, the party seeking permission must be in a position to inform the Tribunal that the relevant foreign government raises no objection to live evidence being given from within its jurisdiction, to a Tribunal or court in the United Kingdom.  The vast majority of countries with which immigration appeals (even asylum appeals) are concerned are countries with which the United Kingdom has friendly diplomatic relations, and it is not for an immigration judge to interfere with those relations by not ensuring that enquiries of this sort have been made, and that the outcome was positive. Enquiries of this nature may be addressed to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (International Legal Matters Unit, Consular Division).  If evidence is given from abroad, a British Embassy, High Commission or Commonwealth may be able to provide suitable facilities.
e.      The application must be served on all other parties, in time for them to have a proper opportunity to respond to it.
f.       The decision whether to grant the application is a judicial one.  The judge making the decision will take into account the reasons supporting the application, any response from other parties and the content of the proposed evidence, as well as of the overriding objective of the rules.  If the application is granted, there may be further specific directions, which must be followed.
g.     If there is a direction for the taking of evidence by electronic link, the Tribunal will nevertheless need to be satisfied that arrangements at the distant end are, and remain, appropriate for the giving of evidence.  A video link, if available, is more likely to be suitable than a telephone link.  The person presiding over the Tribunal hearing must be able to be satisfied that events at the distant site are, so far as may be, within the observation and control of the Tribunal, and that there is no reason to fear any irregularity.
h.     There will need to be arrangements to ensure that all parties at the hearing, as well as the judge, have equal access to the input from the electronic link.  Particular attention needs to be given to the accommodation of any interpreter.
i.       In assessing any challenged evidence, the Tribunal may have to bear in mind any disadvantages arising from the fact that it was given by electronic link, and should be ready to hear and consider submissions on that issue.
j.       Nothing in this guidance is intended to affect the existing arrangements for the hearing of bail applications by video link from secure video conferencing suites. Nor is this guidance intended to affect the arrangements for video linking of one Tribunal room to another for the purposes of hearing submissions by video link.
It is, of course, for the party seeking to rely on evidence given by electronic means to make the arrangements and pay any associated costs. It should hopefully be abundantly clear after all of the above that any applications must be carefully made in very good time and must be well planned.

INVALID APPLICATION


Invalid immigration applications cause serious difficulties. The problem is that the UK Border Agency advises people not to make applications until shortly before their existing leave is due to expire. However, it often takes the Border Agency days or weeks to look at the application, by which time the person’s existing leave has expired. As long as the application was valid, this causes few difficulties because the person’s leave is automatically extended by section 3C of the Immigration Act 1971 until the end of the application or appeal process. A serious problem arises where the Border Agency in their wisdom return the application as invalid: the person becomes an overstayer, commits a criminal offence by even remaining in the UK to re-submit the application, risks a re-entry ban and loses any right of appeal if the re-submitted application is unsuccessful.
There are many reasons why applications are declared invalid. In fact, it is quite difficult to get absolutely everything right. I once acted in a case where an application where it was declared invalid because the applicant had not entered a land line telephone number in the mandatory box. He had no landline. Applications are sometimes rejected because the photographs are too small, too smiley or too frowny. Submitting the incorrect fee (too much or too little does the trick) leads to automatic refusal, despite the difficulties calculating that fee when there are dependents involved. All of this would be good reason to hold the application and ask for further information or repayment, but it is not a good reason to criminalise the person concerned. Some might think that it makes such a mockery of the idea of criminal immigration offending that UKBA can hardly continue to go around saying that overstaying is a serious matter.
There are several cases where these issues have been canvassed. One of the most useful is that of Forrester, which I wrote about at the time. A handy little new case has just come out that may help some people: R (on the application of Kisuule) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2011] EWHC 2966 (Admin). In this case the application was refused on the grounds that photographs were not included at all. The applicant insisted that he was very sure he had included them. The judge sided with him and held that the application had been validly made in the first place. The Border Agency will have had to pay the claimant’s costs.
These invalidity cases are a huge waste of everyone’s time and effort, they make a mockery of a criminal offence and it is high time the Border Agency reverted to the old system where leave was automatically extended for 28 days to give an opportunity to resubmit an application.
 

Monday, November 7, 2011

Watch out old work permit holders !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Back on 6 April 2011 the UK Border Agency made a change to the settlement rules for work permit holders who had entered the UK before the Points Based System was introduced. The change required a work permit holder to be paid a certain salary in order to qualify for settlement, or Indefinite Leave to Remain. The salary required is that specified in the myriad Codes of Practice for Tier 2 of the Points Based System.
The problem since faced by many work permit holder seeking settlement after five years of living and working in the UK is that their work permit was approved for one salary, which is what they have as a consequence been paid by their employer, but suddenly, with no individual warning, that salary level is no longer sufficient and the work permit holder neither qualifies for settlement nor for an extension under Tier 2.
An announcement recently went up on the UK Border Agency website that as of 31 October 2011, work permit holders will not only need to be paid the Code of Practice salary but will need to submit certain specified documents in order to demonstrate this. Previously certification by the employer was sufficient, but no longer.
The 6 April change was clearly an unfair one in the moral sense – the rules of the game were changed without notification. Foreign workers have a potentially difficult relationship with their employer in any event, and negotiating a rise in salary might well have been difficult even had they known one was needed. However, in immigration law it is very difficult to succeed on the basis of a legitimate expectation or a fairness argument. The courts have repeatedly held that there is no legitimate expectation that the Immigration Rules will remain the same. Cases that have succeeded, like the HSMP and BAPIO challenges, were based on specific assurances that the rules would remain the same, assurances that are not normally given. I have myself struggled to come up with a robust legal solution for those facing this problem. Article 8 ECHR is the best I can offer, but I would be interested to hear if anyone has done better.
Those work permit holders coming to the end of their five years and considering applying for settlement would be well advised to make sure they have checked they are paid in accordance with the relevant Code of Practice.

Saturday, August 27, 2011

visa fraud in UK Ravi Gupta and Surge Global Solutions.


A legal advisor from Hayes was jailed on Thursday 18 August for 4.5 years for masterminding a major immigration scam.

Indian national Ravi Gupta, 41, was arrested by our officers from the West London immigration crime team during a dawn raid on his home in Carlyon Road, Hayes in November 2010.

Gupta, an accredited immigration law advisor, supplied dozens of his clients with fake documents, letters, education certificates and payslips to aid immigration applications, helping them to falsify details of their income. He would typically charge up to £5,000 for each application.

His scam was uncovered following an undercover investigation into the practices used by his company, Surge Global Solutions.

Gupta admitted 14 charges of assisting illegal immigration and an additional charge of obtaining leave to remain in the UK by deception. A judge at Isleworth Crown Court sentenced him to 4.5 years in prison and recommended that he be deported at the end of his sentence.

Chris Foster, immigration crime team, UK Border Agency said:
'Gupta ran a sophisticated and lucrative scam, designed to help people who would otherwise have no right to be here stay in the UK.
'I am delighted that we have been able to bring him to justice, along with a number of people who knowingly benefited from his deception.
'His guilty pleas are an indication of the level of professionalism of my team in combating this type of crime and we are determined to continue tackling organised abuse of our immigration laws.'
Proceeds of Crime Act proceedings, designed to confiscate any money Gupta may have made from the scan have now begun.

Sentenced alongside Gupta were Tapinder Singh, 28, and Gurvinderpal Singh, 26, both of Benen-Stock Road in Stanwell Moor, Middlesex. Both admitted obtaining leave to remain by deception and money laundering offences and were each sentenced to 6 months in prison.

A further 4 men and a woman who were also involved in the scam had previously been sentenced to jail terms of between 4 and 8 months after admitting charges of obtaining leave to remain in the UK by deception.

Legal proceedings involving another 6 people suspected of being clients of Ravi Gupta are ongoing.

Damian Green, Minister for Immigration, said:
'This case shows we have stepped up action to tackle serious and organised abuse of our immigration system. The message is clear - the UK is no longer an easy touch.
'This summer we are targeting our efforts on breaking up the gangs behind visa scams; hitting rogue employers who repeatedly break the rules and doing more than ever to stop unwanted people coming to the UK.'
The West London immigration crime team is a specialist unit of police officers seconded from the Metropolitan Police working alongside our warranted officers to investigate organised immigration crime.